Ethiopia: One Nation of Sisters and Brothers

Filed under: News Feature,Opinion |

  • Sumo

By Desta Heliso

Over the last few weeks, I have been following a debate relating to ethnicity, shared national identity and particularly certain people groups in Ethiopia having a common origin. The debate, based on literature produced in different forms, seems to be very heated and emotionally charged. In this brief article, I would like to share my thoughts, for what they are worth, in relation to shared national identity and contribute to the debate. My thesis is very simple: Ethiopia is one and all Ethiopians are sisters and brothers. But to arrive at this deceptively simple proposition, one should accept that Ethiopia as a nation is a political construct and being Ethiopian is a state of mind. Ethiopia, as a nation, was created from different people groups through promotion of ideals that unite these groups and help transcend differences without necessarily dissolving distinct identities and their expressions. This resulted in what we now refer to as shared national identity under a nation-state called Ethiopia. This important construction was achieved over many generations and reinforced by the overarching narrative of Ethiopianness.

 

Very often, this narrative goes back to references to Aithiopis in Homeric poetic legends and Herodotus’ writings. References are also made to the Bible where Ethiopia represents the end of the earth in the extreme south. The Hebrew Bible uses Cush and the Greek Aithiopis. But nominal expressions of Cush or Aithiopis do not represent the status of Ethiopia as we know it today. What the Old Testament refers to as Cushcould include Nubia and the Arabian peninsula. The classical writers’ use of Aithiopis, instead of Cush, may not necessarily negate this. For the Greeks, Aithiopis is ‘a far-off country of a black race who lived by the fountains of the sun’ and Ethiopians were most un-Greek in appearance because they were ‘black and smitten by the sun’. We cannot be absolutely certain as to how the Greeks came up with this name and these expressions. But we know that names are coined to a group of people on the basis of their geographical location, their religious persuasion, their social roots or even their skin colour. It is possible that the ancient Greeks came up with the name Aithiopis because of the skin colour of the ancient Ethiopians. Whatever the case, how many of the people groups in today’s Ethiopia this name represented from the time of Homer to the Roman period, we simply don’t know.

 

As the Greeks portrayed, ancient Ethiopia may well have been a respectable state with well-organised and courageous army. And ancient Ethiopians may well have been freedom- and justice-loving people. The portrayal of Ethiopians by the Jewish historian Josephus, in his Jewish Antiquities, is even more intriguing. He talks about Ethiopia’s prominence as an independent state of considerable military power, the marriage of a beautiful princess of Ethiopia called Tharbis to Moses, and the admirable and wise Queen of Sheba becoming Queen of Egypt and Ethiopia. Josephus’ story of the Queen of Sheba in particular has undergone extensive Arabian and other elaborations. It was further elaborated in a unique manner in the 14th century Ethiopia in a document called Kebra Nagast. According to these elaborations, Yemenis, Egyptians, Ethiopians etc could claim that the Queen of Sheba was their Queen. Then, which territories did Sheba represent? I don’t think we can say that it represented only the present political and geographical Ethiopia. I met a Kenyan who argued that ancient Ethiopia included some parts of Kenya. He may or may not be right. All this leads one to conclude that we cannot know with any degree of certainty as to how much of the land and which groups of people of the present Ethiopia were part of that ancient Cush, Sheba or Aithiopis.

 

What we can safely claim, however, is that a nation-state called Ethiopia was created and recreated, defined and redefined. From the history of Ethiopia, we know that the goal of creating and recreating, defining and redefining Ethiopia – as we know her today – was politically and economically motivated. It was achieved predominantly through bloody battles, political manipulations and imposition of certain ideals. We have moved from disparate kingdoms – whose vassals were loosely connected to the Suzerain – to T’eqlay Gizats under Emperor, then to Kifle Hegers under President, and now to Kilels under Prime Minister. Goodness knows what kind of administrative arrangements the next generation will come up with. All this shows that the concept of ‘nation’ is not a fixed one.

 

Prof Kwame Anthony Appiah in his BBC 4 Reith Lectures 2016 – titled Mistaken Identities(with special reference to Creed, Country, Colour and Culture) – argued that the idea of national sovereignty has ‘an incoherence at heart’ and that a nation is defined and redefined and political unity is never underwritten by some ‘pre-existing national commonality’. I agree with Appiah. Ethiopia’s singular nationhood is dependent not on pre-existing national commonality but on previously disparate people groups with their own autonomous or semi-autonomous territories accepting ideals believed to transcend differences without dissolving certain particularities; associating themselves with shared historical and cultural values and aspirations; developing national consciousness; and committing themselves to a shared national identity under a shared narrative of Ethiopianness.

 

Ethiopianness is a unifying state of mind developed by people of different ethnic groups, cultural backgrounds and religious persuasions. It is a mental disposition shaped by ‘history’ and ‘traditions’ of Ethiopia. It is something that is so deeply embedded in the societal psyche that it is almost unconscious. It is an inner passion for and emotional bond with the country, which can be described as love for Ethiopia. Through music, arts, sport and national anthem, this passion is rekindled and commitment to the uniting symbols is renewed. The whole thing can at times border on the irrational and can even be dangerous if it is not kept in check through rational reasoning. One cannot explain it comprehensively but it is a reality.

 

In Britain, a concert called BBC Proms is organised every year. It takes place in the Royal Albert Hall. In the final night of the Proms, one of the final songs refers to Britain or England as the Land of Hope and Glory. Another one is the well-known Rule Britannia. Many young people would wrap themselves with the British flag and sing these songs with incredible enthusiasm and tears in their eyes. The reference in the songs is to the colonial Britain, about which they are often embarrassed, and is of no relevance to the Britain they know and live in today, but it still seems to emotionally charge and strengthen their sense of Britishness and their love for Britain. This feeling is not always explicable but it is there for good or ill.

 

Similarly, Ethiopianness is something abstract, mentally constructed and emotionally strengthened. It is a unifying narrative that is shared by more than eighty people groups who have happened or chosen to live on a piece of land and share God-given resources together. These groups also voluntarily share common values, common cultural heritage and expressions, and uniting symbols. Through this, the vast majority of them have come to recognise and love this country called Ethiopia. Shared narrative has resulted in shared identity, so they have become – to use a metaphor – children of the same parent. That is, they have become sisters and brothers. Like all sisters and brothers, of course, they engage in sibling rivalry (sometimes in a rather unhealthy and deadly manner). But they could still love that Ethiopia with her symbolic motherhood. What they actually love is not that geographically determined land of beauty and serenity or that incorporeal political construct. What they actually love are those women and men whose lives and historical destinies are tied up with that of a country called Ethiopia. It is, therefore, unhelpful or even futile to attempt to prove that certain people groups in Ethiopia (to the exclusion of others) have a shared origin and identity. We should all declare in unison that Ethiopia is one and all Ethiopians are sisters and brothers!

6 Responses to Ethiopia: One Nation of Sisters and Brothers

  1. GREAT ANALYSIS, THANK YOU BROTHER.

    aleneger
    January 17, 2017 at 8:16 am
    Reply

  2. That is indeed very deep! I like see more often such a strong and heartening narrative than useless pieces that bent on making our differences as a source of discord and of identity crisis. I applaud you for the depth and breath of our thoughts. God bless you!

    Bendene Guleta
    January 17, 2017 at 11:21 am
    Reply

  3. Ato Desta Heliso, thank you for breaking out of the shell of hate group of so called elites who always undermine the common identity we have developed through generations. I really share your observation that there has been a shared Ethiopian identity. Yes we are all the siblings under the parenthood of Ethiopia. But, don’t forget some sibling members have gone to the extreme corner of hatred and labeled their “brothers and sisters” as their enemies.The Amharas have been the target of hate that resulted in their massacre, displacement, mass arrest, torture, denigration etc. While the Amhara elites and the poor mass have been preoccupied with ” Ethiopianess”, TPLF has worked hard and succeeded in the last 40 years to campaign and spread anti-Amhara narratives. The results are, Assosa, Bedeno, Woter, Arbagugu, Gonder, Gojam, Guraferda, Horoguduru massacres, where unprecedented innermost brutality and inhumanity were manifested.
    Do not also forget that within the broad Ethiopian identity, there are subsets of identities. Using your metaphor, brother and sister siblings have their own individual and family identities. All children of a parent should be loved, respected and treated equally. Only bad governments should be hated and punished through the ballot.
    You wrote, “Like all sisters and brothers, of course, they engage in sibling rivalry (sometimes in a rather unhealthy and deadly manner). But they could still love that Ethiopia with her symbolic motherhood.” I can take you to be a person of good heart for this conciliatory message. But what TPLF has been doing against the Amharas, cannot be accommodated in here. It may take another generation of Amharas to forget and forgive TPLF and its supporters. At present the Amharas are endangered ethnic group. That is why the present generation of the Amharas, especially the young are engaged, as you wrote, in a “very heated and emotionally charged” battle to organize the Amharas in order to survive first and then coexist within the embrace of mother Ethiopia.
    Long live each ethnic group, including the Amharas, in peace and prosperity in our mother land, Ethiopia!

    Samma from Nashville
    January 17, 2017 at 3:41 pm
    Reply

  4. Thank you The Real Genuine and Honest Ethiopian ATO Desta Heliso,For being a voice for the Voiceless Millions of Ethiopians.While Others Clueless writers wasting our time and theirs by WRITTING back and forth for months. Just to show us How bigger their Personal ego is bigger than the Other senseless Writers
    Thanks again ATO Desta Heliso

    Saleh M. NUR
    January 18, 2017 at 5:01 am
    Reply

  5. Interesting article Dr Desta Heliso?. No need to waste time exploring unfounded history. The fact is simple: We all are Ethiopians not only the 3 ethnic groups whose elites are obsessed with power and rivalry even to the extent of destroying the country for their selfish interest. Ethiopia would be much better if we get rid off elites from these 3 ethnic groups who are the source of curse and poverty of the country as we witnessed for centuries. It is time for those from south, west and east Ethiopia to salvage the country.

    Anamo
    January 18, 2017 at 12:28 pm
    Reply

  6. Since when were we sisters and brothers? Never, right? We were neighbors not that close relatives. With the coming independence of my drop dead beautiful Oromia, we will forcefully re-establish the state of peaceful neighborhood with the neftegnas at a safe distance. Look at what the neftegnas are doing to my gallant Oromos. They are building what they call a ‘Renaissance’ Dam on the Blue Nile River. There is a sinister plan behind this major project. Their wicked objective is to drain every drop of water and soil moisture out of Oromia and turn the current lush landscape into barren environment just like that forsaken region of Tigray. You don’t know this devil’s scheme because you are either too naive or outright stupid. What the dam will do is (if the plan materialize) drain and suck away every drop of water from the proven vast aquifer that is present below the surface throughout Oromia. You know science. It does that by the natural process of osmosis. This was discovered by the most famous scientists in the world who are Oromos now teaching at the ten top universities in America. Tigres and Ammaro Sayyontes are just only the multiple lenticular images of the same devil’s hologram. They claim that the dam is needed to provide electric power. For what? To grow more cactus trees in Tigray and their neftegna friends’ regions? That is why the first action on order when my Oromia becomes independent nation next month to see to it that the demolition of this dam will begin in earnest right away. That is located in my Oromo territory anyway. It also endangers the lives of millions who are our good neighbors all the way to the Mediterranean Sea.

    My Oromia is coming!!! My Oromia is coming!!! My Independent Democratic Republic of Oromia is Coming Next Month!!!!!!

    Hordofaa
    January 24, 2017 at 11:12 pm
    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *