Is Eritrea coming in from the cold?

Filed under: News |


Last year Eritrea’s leader, Isaias Afewerqi, and Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed signed a historic peace deal

For decades the Eritrean economy has struggled due to a combination of war, dictatorship and the impact of United Nations sanctions.

But the East African country’s recent rapprochement with its southern neighbour, Ethiopia, and the end of the embargoes, means that its economy now has a chance to grow substantially.

The hope is that the nation will export more to the world than people fleeing the country.

But as Eritrea continues to be an authoritarian one-party state, with a heavily militarised society, substantial hurdles remain. It is also one of the poorest countries in Africa, with a mostly agriculture-based economy.

Trucks cross the Eritrea-Ethiopia borderImage copyrightGETTY IMAGES
Image captionGoods have been flowing across the Eritrea-Ethiopia border since last summer

Yemane, an Eritrean expat living in Europe, is part of the country’s vast diaspora.

An estimated 1.5 million Eritreans now live overseas, more often after escaping poverty, or the country’s indefinite military service. This is more than one in five of all Eritreans.

Yemane was recently back in Eritrea on holiday, in the city of Massawa on the country’s Red Sea coast. He also used the visit to do some business research.

His company imports Ethiopian beer into Europe, and he hopes to start being able to export it via Massawa. “This would be much easier for my business,” he says.

SoldiersImage copyrightGETTY IMAGES
Image captionMost of Eritrea’s active labour force is employed in defence

Presently the entrepreneurial ex-pat has to ship the bottles via the the small coastal country of Djibouti, to Eritrea’s south east.

This had been the case for all of land-locked Ethiopia’s ground and sea exports ever since its 1998 to 2000 border war with Eritrea meant the country could no longer access Eritrean ports. It led to a Cold War-style standoff between the two countries for the next 18 years.

But in July 2018, Abiy Ahmed, Ethiopia’s new Prime Minister, signed a historic peace deal with Eritrea’s longstanding President Isaias Afwerki, and the border between the two country’s re-opened.

It means that Ethiopian merchandise has once again started flowing into Eritrea, while Eritreans have been heading south to shop in northern Ethiopian towns.

Then, in November of last year, the UN lifted its sanctions against Eritrea that had been in place for nine years.

These included an arms embargo, an asset freeze, and a travel ban. They had been put in place after Eritrea was accused of supporting Islamist militants in Somalia – something it denied.

While the four border crossings between Eritrea and Ethiopia are currently officially closed again, this is said to be a short-term move only.

“It appears a temporary closure until they regulate tax, customs and visa issues,” says Associated Press journalist Elias Meseret, who covers the two countries.

Eritrean man working in French factoryImage copyrightGETTY IMAGES
Image captionMany Eritreans have left the country to find work

It comes as the Ethiopian Ministry of Transport says it is moving ahead with plans for bus services across the border. And another reporter, freelancer Elias Gebreselassie, says that “people and goods are still crossing informally” between the two countries.

Eritrea – which gained its independence from Ethiopia in 1993 – used to be famous for its entrepreneurialism and trade ties.

This owed much to outside influence – the country has seen influxes of Arabs, Turks and Yemenis throughout its history. Not to forget Italian and British rule.

The Italians were in charge from 1890 to 1941, and the British from 1941 to 1950. Eritrea then became part of Ethiopia.

Mine in EritreaImage copyrightGETTY IMAGES
Image captionGold, copper and zinc are mined in Eritrea’s western Bisha area

“There is a popular saying in Eritrea – ‘let the farmers farm, and the traders trade’,” says Tekle Woldemikael, a sociology professor at Chapman University in California, who was born in Eritrea.

“It means that Eritreans value the possibility to do trade in open and unrestricted markets.”

Sadly, in recent decades the Eritrean economy has been gutted, first by the country’s 30-year fight for independence, then by the 1998-2000 border war.

And the economy is still being profoundly affected by the government’s far left economics.

Massawa portImage copyrightMILENA BELLONI
Image captionCould Massawa port become a hub for trade?

“Eritrea’s economic stagnation is rooted in the communist government’s profound antipathy to free trade and capitalism, not the war, and that’s not going to end because of the truce,” says Michela Wrong, who wrote a book on Eritrea’s fight for independence.

Currently, the government limits each person to withdrawing 5,000 Nakfa (about $330; £250) a month from banks, ostensibly to tackle the currency black market, but this hinders private initiatives and entrepreneurialism.

This is compounded by continued mandatory national service, which leaves most young people “serving the nation” in the military or in government ministries for extremely limited salaries.

Nicole Hirt of the GIGA Institute of African Affairs, in Hamburg, is also pessimistic about the possibility of an economic renaissance in Eritrea.

“The problem is the infrastructure has been completely neglected,” she says. “I would warn against being over optimistic, because the ruling elite has always tried to control the economy, and has left very little space for private investors.”

Currently, the country’s only significant export is gold mined in the western Bisha area and sent to China and South Korea. However, there is growing interest in doing business with Eritrea around the world.

At the end of 2018, a group of about 80 Italian investors representing sectors such as energy, construction and agriculture, visited Eritrea with the Italian Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs, Emanuela Del Re.

A map showing Ethiopia and Eritrea
Image captionThe disputed border town of Badme was at the heart of the war between the two countries, whose capitals as Asmara and Addis Ababa

“Of course, Eritrea has huge potential to export,” says Ms Hirt. “After World War Two, it was one of the most industrialised areas in Africa.

“[Today] fish could be exported in large quantities, as well as marble, potash, gold, copper, zinc, textiles, processed food, hides, meat, wine and beer.”

A spokesman for the Eritrean government said that the country’s large diaspora could help boost the economy. Most already send back cash to their families, and, officially, ex-pats have to pay a 2% tax on income earned abroad.

In fact, some estimate that about 30% of Eritrea’s gross domestic product is derived from money sent back to the country.

Italy's Deputy Foreign Minister, Emanuela Del ReImage copyrightGETTY IMAGES
Image captionItaly’s Deputy Foreign Minister, Emanuela Del Re, is keen to build trade ties with Eritrea

But while ex-pats like Yemane are looking at renewing their ties, other commentators warn against any expectation of rapid change in the country.

“Eritrea needs to develop its own basic food security before thinking about exports,” says Victoria Bernal, an anthropology professor at the University of California, and an expert on the country.

“They also cannot do international business without strengthening their ICT [information and communications] infrastructure.”

Ms Hirt adds that most potential international investors are also likely to hold back until they see real political reform in the country.

2 Responses to Is Eritrea coming in from the cold?

  1. First of all, the number of Eritreans living abroad is estimated to be more than the population that is living in Eritrea. I am not sure where you got the 1.5 million number. You may have just added up only Eritreans that reside in the Western hemisphere. Second, the lifting of sanctions is useless. The sanction that needs to be lifted is the one that is imposed by the current government on the Eritrean people for decades. If change occurs within the country, I am certain the Eritrean people will work hard and improve their economy and their own lives. For that, democracy must happen within the country. These fly by night expatriate going back and forth to Eritrea to amuse themselves will not do any worthwhile work unless the current political situation changes.
    As indicated, if Eritrea continues to be an authoritarian one-party state the pain and agony of the Eritrean people will continue an abated. Western countries and the the Arabs will just add fuel to the fire for us to continue to kill each other to benefit themselves. That is what has happened in the past and it is not much different today. As Mohammed Gaddafi, Saddam Hussein and Omar – Al Bashir used to say “My people loves me”. that is just till the cut you into pieces or throw you into the dungeons you were subjecting your people. It is time for the President of Eritrea, to respect the constitution and to pass the baton to the next generation before he is forcefully and hopefully without bloodshed gets removed from power. otherwise, I agree with Hirut. Without a real political reform, potential investors will not involve their resource in Eritrea. Of course the likes of China, will do anything to pillage the people of Africa. However, China is a totalitarian country with no true freedom to its people. That is not a good friend to have for a dictator and its people that are suppressed for ages.

    Tesfa
    May 10, 2019 at 5:55 am
    Reply

  2. The BBC never writes anything positive about Eritrea. It always aims to demoralize Eritrea and Eritreans! Very hateful and a bully!

    Hanna
    May 10, 2019 at 1:22 pm
    Reply

Leave a Reply to Tesfa Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.