Nobel Peace Prize for Abiy Ahmed a misguided decision

Filed under: Opinion |

DW

The Ethiopian laureate is surely a reformer, but he predominantly garners recognition beyond his country’s borders. Despite the Nobel committee’s well-meaning intentions, it is the wrong choice, writes Ludger Schadomsky.

Ethiopia’s PM Abiy Ahmed signed the peace treaty with neighboring Eritrea on September 16, 2018 — after which progress ground to a standstill

Despite a number of somewhat questionable recipients — such as former US President Barack Obama, or the European Union — the Nobel Peace Prize continues to carry considerable symbolic meaning. For precisely this reason, awarding it to the young reformer hailing from Addis Ababa despite the stalled progress on his peace initiative is also the wrong choice.

Peace with Eritrea? Or dead silence?

Abiy Ahmed took office in April 2018, becoming PM of Africa’s second-most populous nation, which also holds tremendous geostrategic importance. Let there be no misunderstanding: Since taking office he has pushed for reforms , the importance of which are impossible to overestimate. He unlocked the torture chambers and took the muzzle away from the media. All of this deserves unqualified respect, even if, in the meantime, the initial euphoria has waned a little.

Of course, Abiy was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize to a lesser extent because of his “important reforms” in the domestic domain but explicitly because of his efforts regarding a lasting peace with Ethiopia’s archrival Eritrea — the two countries were involved in a border war from 1998 to 2000, which led to heavy losses on both sides. And wasn’t it a very moving scene indeed in July 2018 when, Abiy made it possible for family members separated for two decades to embrace each other again?

DW's Ludger Schadomsky

Ludger Schadomsky is the head of DW’s Amharic desk

Those peace efforts, however, have come to a standstill; they may even have stopped completely. True, family members and businesspeople are now able to commute via 50-minute flights between the two respective capitals, Addis Ababa and Asmara. But this is the privilege of only a small elite. Border crossings such as Zalambessa, which are much more important when it comes to public transportation and movement of goods and which were opened with a lot of fanfare, have all been closed again in the meantime — at Eritrea’s instigation, Ethiopia was quick to point out. The initial shuttle diplomacy pursued by Abiy and Eritrea’s autocratic ruler Isaias Afewerki has come to a halt. The Eritrean embassy in Addis Ababa continues to remain boarded up while grandiose business contracts that were signed have never been brought to life. By now, both countries have rather resorted to forging unholy strategic alliances with countries located beyond the Red Sea, in accordance with that age-old motto that Horn of Africa nations ascribe to: “The enemy of my enemy is my friend.”

Will the Prize eventually endanger peace efforts?

So Abiy has received the most prestigious peace prize for a peace that exists, predominantly, only on paper. Worse still: the award could, eventually, even torpedo those peace efforts, if the Eritrean leadership felt put under pressure to an even greater extent than before. The grumpy autocrat from Asmara, who ruthlessly keeps his own people in chains so he can remain in power, is unlikely to enjoy being snubbed under the eyes of the world by a charismatic politician half his age.

Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed wins Nobel Peace Prize

Everybody’s darling on the world stage, vociferous criticism at home

On the domestic politics level, the award provides ammunition to those critics who have slammed the young and dynamic Prime Minister’s approach to politics as detached from reality and insubstantial. In an Ethiopia that is socially conservative to the core, the prime minister’s PR-guided demeanor — accompanied by an unprecedented “Abiymania” — has sparked some resentful allegations that the former secret service agent is engaged in illicit activities benefitting his ethnic group, the Oromo.

But it’s not just his fellow Ethiopians who view him with criticism —  his development policy partners also view with concern the young PM’s personality cult and style of government – which is sometimes rather erratic and lacking in communication.

Is Abiy’s reconciliation policy sustainable?

Unfortunately, Abiy’s award is evocative of the one given in 2000 to former South Korean President Kim Dae-jung, who had been in office for only two years before he received the Nobel Peace Prize for his efforts to reunite the divided Korean nation. North and South Korea, however, are divided to this day.

Currently, there’s a lot of talk about “Medemer,” Abiy’s programmatic policy of reconciliation. One day before he was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize, Abiy had invited heads of state and government from all over the region to take part in a huge “Medemer” celebration. Sudan, Somalia and Uganda all sent their representatives while only one distinguished guest was absent — Eritrean President Afewerki, Abiy’s partner in the “reconciliation” process. It is likely that the award of the Nobel Peace Prize has raised the bar for Abiy instead of lowering it.

https://p.dw.com/p/3R9KM

6 Responses to Nobel Peace Prize for Abiy Ahmed a misguided decision

  1. DW is another Ethsat/Ethio-360 studio in Germany. It always airs anti-Oromo views. Therefore, it is not surprising to hear bad talks about the Oromo from DW. The station is happy that Ethiopia gets the prize but unhappy that it is Abiy who received. If it were a qomchamba naftagna who won the prize, DW stuff would dance naked.

    Avatar for alganesh

    alganesh
    October 12, 2019 at 11:54 pm
    Reply

  2. Isn’t the same ‘news’ joint that read the names Ethiopian soldiers killed in one of the engagements during the senseless war with Eritrea in 2000 right on its radio broadcast? Also how in this day and age it is not an Ethiopian or with such heritage who is in charge here? Sir! You better look at your own backyard. Neo-Nazis are lurking in your own back alleys. You should worry about those demons. We know how to tame ours on our own. Sir, please leave us alone. That country is at cross roads with simmering tensions. The worst thing it needs is someone throwing gasoline on the outside looking in. Leave us alone. It is not funny!!!!!

    Avatar for Ittu Aba Farda

    Ittu Aba Farda
    October 13, 2019 at 2:50 am
    Reply

  3. Ethiopian government in early 1998 was best friends with the Eritrean government. Within a matter of few months Eritrean government became worst enemies with the Ethiopian government.
    Unless the core reason of the Ethio-Eritrean war is adressed not one but hundreds of peace prizes do not bring lasting peace between the two countries. Both sides need to figure out what it was that turned the best of friends relationship they had into the worst of enemies that quick , then both countries leaders must instill in themselves and in their whole countries people to do a conscious effort the reason that brought the Ethio Eritean war doesn’t happen again.

    Sugar-coating the real reason of why the Ethio-Eritrean war started, by saying the reason was the two cousins family feud (Meles Zenawi’s and Isayas Afeworki’s) personal feud war or border war over Badme, is not the way peace is achieved.

    The real truth of why the war started need to be addressed.

    Avatar for Dagmawit

    Dagmawit
    October 13, 2019 at 3:25 am
    Reply

  4. Aye yesew neger,

    Out of no where you jump on Amhara.Why? Even though you Galas are controlling the Minilik palace, still, you are not cured from your inferiority complex, your worst disease.

    Poor gala

    Avatar for Meseret

    Meseret
    October 13, 2019 at 9:34 am
    Reply

  5. Anchi Timb stinky gala,

    What the DW director said is 100% true. This serpent gala PM is there to promote KEGNA politics of Jo-war, the Alkaida representative in East Africa. Gala Abiy is there to lay the foundation for the future gala land. Your neofascist gala youth is harassing Addisababans in their own country, the same group blocked roads causing the suffering of thousands of Ethiopians, hanged people upside down, carried out ethnic cleansing in Gedeo etc

    The gala PM, if he was the PM of all Ethiopians, should have said, no, stop it. Did he say that? No and will never do that as he is there only for gala.

    When gala Abiy came to power and talked a lot about “suse”, “simot ethiopia” etc, all Ethiopians were euphoric. One year later, when gala Abiy received the prize he does not deserve, galas were the only ones who expressed their joy.

    Avatar for meseret

    meseret
    October 13, 2019 at 11:14 pm
    Reply

  6. Ludger – Your twisted comment about the 2019 Peace prize award reflects your derogatory and bias stance. Was anyone critical when Mikhail Gorbachev was given the award in 1990? What was his achievement? Was it the unification of East and West Germany? No! The peace prize was given to him for his capitulation to the demand of the West.
    It is clear Ethiopia’s PM achieved much in a short period of time. thousands prisoners are released from prison without any precondition. The peace agreement with Eritrea is achieved without a 3rd party involvement. It was negotiated and agreed between the two leaders. That by itself is a great achievement. Yes, he has a lot to do. Nonetheless, his current words and actions on the ground testify he is determined to change the lives of the Ethiopian people and beyond. That is worth the 2019 Peace Prize award. Stop lamenting and celebrate his achievements and the prize that is given to the Ethiopian PM and to Africa.

    Avatar for Tesfa

    Tesfa
    October 14, 2019 at 10:14 am
    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.